Any discussion of inequality includes an implicit normative or ethical comparison of distributions; a certain distribution of some good, or of gains in that good, is acceptable or not acceptable, is better or worse, is improving or stagnating. If discussions of inequality also inevitably involve rankings and comparisons of different distributions, then how inequality is . The choice of measurement of inequality is therefore not value neutral.Read More »
Category: Inequality
What do we know about the wealthy in India? A case study prior to liberalization
The first modern book in economics was called the 鈥淲ealth of Nations鈥 because its writer, Adam Smith understood (and transmuted the idea) that the key to prosperity and growth was the generation and distribution of wealth – not just the flow of income. Recent interest in economics has started to return to this question especially in the context of today鈥檚 rich countries. The academic attention on the metamorphosis and concentration of wealth has so far excluded poor countries. In fact the study of the wealth of poor nations should be a core question in development economics (over income growth) because wealth tends to cumulate all past prosperity or disparity.
I found it notable that despite the detailed historical analysis in Piketty鈥檚 book , there was no mention of Indian wealth (Piketty did study top Indian incomes). To an extent this is understandable because data on India is so limited and unreliable that documenting it would require a book in itself. Till date, the Indian central bank (RBI) does not follow the tradition of publishing regular household and private sector balance sheets at market value, to assess accumulation and asset prices. And yet due to its sheer size and importance, India presents a unique challenge to the notion of prosperity – it is simultaneously home to some of the and global citizens. In the past, the question of India鈥檚 colonial subservience was related to the , rather than income – the British enriched themselves at the cost of their prized colony. What happened once India became independent?
My new paper 鈥溾 tries to answer this question for a particular historical phase in Indian history. Read More »